7 Elements of Effective Learning Teams

Collaborative learning, groupwork, learning teams–whatever you want to call it–has one major problem: it just doesn’t work out-of-the-box. However, I find that most educators expect collaborative learning to be more intuitive. In the process of writing my next book on online instruction, I’ve been reading some really helpful literature on working with learning groups (which I believe to be a critical skill for online instructors). I’d like to synthesize some of what I’ve discovered through both research an practice in this post. Feel free to use and share the 4×6 card posted above.

  1. Group Size

  2. An ideal size for online learning teams will be 5-8 students. Different studies say different things, but they usually fall into this general range. A group of 5-8 is large enough to include students with varying points of view and a variety of strengths. I used to recommend 4-6, but this approach had two problems: a) groups of 4 tend to break up into two pairs, and b) attrition in an online classes caused either by withdraws or by nonparticipating students impacts smaller group sizes. A group that starts out at 7 or 8 usually turns out to be a group of 5-7.

  3. Organize Around a Clear Goal

  4. Give your learning teams time to get to know one another and to discuss their learning goals. Provide a clear learning goal with each assignment. This may seem obvious, but you’d be surprised how often we overlook this simple practice.

  5. Stay in the Same Group

  6. While variety is the spice of life, don’t change things up. It takes time to build the cohesion and trust necessary for learning teams to thrive. The need for a variety of voices can be solved by creating larger learning groups (see #1).

  7. Allow Roles to Emerge.

  8. Assigning team roles, like scribe, reporter, team lead, etc. short-circuits an important process. Each learning team is made up of individuals with a unique expertise and strengths. It’s better to allow learning teams to negotiate their roles and to discover their most natural way of relating with one another.

  9. Create Team Assignments

  10. If your learning teams use the divide-and-conquer approach, then you’ve not created a true team-learning assignment. This is where most groupwork either succeeds or goes off the rails. Good team learning assignments will require deliverables that cannot be done alone or in pairs. They require deliberation by the entire team. Your assignments/projects must require your learners to provide solutions to problems or come to a decision through a process of consensus building.

  11. Build in Accountability

  12. Michaelson and his colleagues, in their book, Team-Based Learning: A Transformative Use of Small Groups in College Teaching, make it clear that for collaborative learning to be successful, students must have two forms of accountability: a) group accountability/grades, and b) individual grades. They also stress the importance of individual assessment prior to beginning group assignments. This ensures that each individual group member comes to the group prepared.

  13. Provide Feedback

  14. This is where you bring your instructional guidance, help your students to negotiate team conflicts, point them to the best resources, and help them to ask better questions when they are stuck. Each learning team will have different needs, so you’ll need to tailor your coaching to each group. When working with several learning teams of High School seniors, I discovered that it was important to drop in as often as I could. A few questions I found helpful were: What have you accomplished that you are proud of as a team? What are you finding most challenging? What questions do you have for me? You’ll notice that each of these questions assumes that there is a response. I try to stay away from questions that begin with phrases such as, “Is there anything that…” or “Have you encountered…” These elicit closed, yes/no responses an binary thinking. Whereas the open questions I provided above help to stir up exploratory thinking.

Recommended Resources

Team-Based Learning Collaborative: http://teambasedlearning.org

Fink LD, Knight AB, Michaelsen LK (2004) Team-based learning: a transformative use of small groups in college teaching. Stylus Publ., Sterling, VA

Bean, J. C. (2011). Engaging ideas: the professors guide to integrating writing, critical thinking, and active learning in the classroom. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. (see his chapter on working with learning groups)

 

Online Teaching Tip #29 – Why the First Weeks of Your Course are So Critical

Why the First Weeks of the Semester are so Critical Here's a quick way to get a picture of student participation in your class: 1. Click on your participants list in your course site. 2. Then sort you students by their last access date. … [Continue reading]

Online Teaching Tip #28 – Calendar Your Baseline Participation

How Much Should I Participate? One of the first questions I get from those who are new to teaching online goes something like this, "How much time should I be spending in the online classroom?" It's hard to really give an accurate number because … [Continue reading]

Online Teaching Tip #27 – Dealing with the Disconnect in the Online Classroom

View image | gettyimages.com The Disconnect Because we don't see or hear our students in the online classroom, we can begin to forget that they exist. Or, at least, we feel less connected to them. This is one of the challenges of both online … [Continue reading]

Teaching Case Studies Online: A Resource List

View image | gettyimages.com View image | gettyimages.com Teaching Case Studies Online: A Resource List It's difficult to find a good set of resources for teaching online case studies. While researching how to structure and moderate online case … [Continue reading]

Online Teaching Tip #26 – Your Tone Matters in Teaching Online

A Story of Miscommunication … [Continue reading]

Online Teaching Tip #25 – The Power of Invitation

One of your primary roles as an online teacher is the role of invitor. I'm not even sure if that's a real word. If it is, perhaps it should be spelled inviter--but that just doesn't look right. So, we'll go with invitor. In the face-to-face classroom … [Continue reading]

Assess Your Online Course with the CHICO Rubic

Here's an award winning resource to use to quickly assess your online course. The Rubric For Online Instruction was developed by California State Univeristy, Chico in 2003, and they have continued to revise it over the years. With it, you can break … [Continue reading]

Online Teaching Tip #24 – Give Them Structure

I've been touching on some common bad habits that online teachers fall into. Tip #22 addressed the bad habit of checking email as the first thing you do in your teaching day or week. Tip #23 addressed the bad habits that flow from an obsession with … [Continue reading]

Online Teaching Tip #23 – A Bad Habit To Avoid

If you've read through some of these online teaching tips, or read my book, Excellent Online Teaching, you've picked up on the fact that I believe good online teaching is built on good habits. You've probably had a teacher in high school or college … [Continue reading]